Somehow, I ended up adding eyeshadow and coming up with this look.
I actually really liked it, and it seemed simple to met, yet it was defined, and I felt like it really brought out my eyes.
I don't remember the exact placement of eyeshadows because I was kind of just going a long with it and adding whatever I deemed fit, but I will list what I used.
Last photo was taken without flash.
Annabelle Eye Kohl e/l in Chestnut
Annabelle Eye Kohl in Black
MAC Night Maneuvers e/s
MAC Cork e/s
MAC Espresso e/s
MAC Femme Fi e/s
Wet n' Wild Color Icon Vanity palette - matte black e/s
Wet n' Wild Color Icon e/s in Brulee
Maybelline Falsies mascara
Eyebrows: MAC Night Maneuvers e/s